I recently had to write an essay for my clinical supervision class on the topic "how is empathy." It is one of the best things I have been asked to put on paper since I started grad school, because it isn't about academia and facts and touting my newfound knowledge. It is about examining a human skill, trait, necessity. So I will post the essay here. It is a long one so hold on to your hats...
The phone rings. It is late, and I don’t feel like answering. I don’t want to talk to anyone. I silence the ringer and a bit later go back to listen to the message via voicemail. Just hearing her voice brings tears to my eyes. In her message to me, she speaks tentatively at first but soon her voice breaks into a full sob. The unmistakable sorrow in her tone seeps through the phone receiver and I feel it run like a current down my spine. She has just heard the news of my father’s death.
Empathy involves a giver and a receiver. In my experience it is sometimes impossible to determine who is who...perhaps they both fulfill each role at one time or another? The receiver owns the pain, the joy, and the guilt – the raw reality of their experience. It is theirs and they know it well. The giver doesn’t own the experience, and may not even understand it all, but they are willing to at least try it on for a while. In trying on, encountering empathy is like holding onto the essence of a feeling or experience. It feels like a weight; and though as the giver you might not be holding up the exact same object as the receiver, you are able to grasp an understanding of how heavy the lifting can be.
The car is cold. I start the engine and turn up the heat as I throw my CD player and scarves in the backseat. As I begin to drive away from the building in this strange yet real way I sense that she is still with me. The way we danced, the words and feelings that were shared – when our eyes locked, I could tell in hers that she knew I got it. It was as though our souls touched for a fleeting moment, as if we were so connected that for just a second I saw and felt the world from her point of view. Hours have passed…why do I still have a remnant of her sadness lingering in my chest?
I sense this thing called empathy creating a nest for itself in my body. I guess it plans to be around for a while. It sits somewhere around the base of my sternum, lodged safely between my rib bones and spinal column, just to the right of my heart. When the nest is especially full, I can feel the shared emotion bubbling up towards my clavicle bones and into my neck. Sometimes my empathy’s home becomes so full that the emotion wells up far enough to make my voice crack. If it wells up even further it brings tears to my eyes. The more full my nest becomes, the closer I know I am to empathy. I am closer to being with the other in their experience. At times, their view is so real to me that my empathy nest becomes flooded and my own body is overcome with emotion. Even swimming in fear and pain I love those moments, and believe they are there to remind me of how alive I am, and thus how able I am to be in relationship with others. It is frightening. It is rewarding. It lives in my chest.
The room is large, uncomfortably large. It is packed with people – family and friends and coworkers and colleagues. The talking and busyness in the hall can’t drown out the all encompassing mourning hanging like a large umbrella in the air. I am over stimulated, my eyes drifting until they land on a group of women near the entrance. Our eyes meet and we all break into tears. As I embrace them, each one traveling miles to be by my side, I can feel it through the labored breathing and the shaking torsos. They get it. Somehow they have found a way to touch my sadness. They didn’t even really know him, but they can feel my grief. And although it is different, for that moment in time, it is their grief too.
Empathy is difficult. Difficult to achieve and difficult to let go of once you’ve found it. It appears to be another of life’s finely tuned skills – just when you think you’ve mastered it, you slip up and find yourself back at step one. I believe empathy is so inherently complicated because we can’t just know what another person is going through. We might say “oh, I know” but really, we don’t. How foolish to think that we, in our individual uniqueness, could know something that belongs to someone else? Perhaps we say, “I know” when what we really mean is “I care.” I care enough to show you that in my own way I have felt something akin to what you are feeling now. I care enough to try and know, and at the very least, I care enough to be there. And the deep desire to care so much you want to know, well, sometimes that is all you need. The empathy will come.
I am walking. I am always walking. And thinking. My bag weighs down on my shoulders, a literal reminder of my emotional heaviness. In light of the past months I feel older than my 20 years. I keep cycling back to what my parents used to tell us about “everyone having their own crosses to bear.” I feel, for the first time in my life, like I am carrying my cross. In my whole being I now can understand what the old saying means. No one else is hauling this with them wherever they go. No one else remembers that it weighs on me all of the time. It makes me feel alone. People try, and I love them for that, but no one really gets it just in the way that I do. And they never will. Somehow, though, I can find solace in the fact that while I have to carry my own cross, I am not responsible for carrying all of the others too.
Empathy is the ability to constantly remind yourself that everyone has their own story, their own “stuff,” or as it has been so many times put to me, “their own cross to bear.” This image especially helps me grasp onto empathy, because I bring to mind the image of Jesus carrying the cross. People tried to help him as he struggled to walk, stepping in for a moment to share the weight, but no one’s experience was comparable. While considering this, another phrase comes to mind – “stand in someone else’s shoes for a while.” Just like no one can fully understand the weight of Jesus’ cross, empathy isn’t exactly like standing in someone else’s shoes. It is more like standing so close to those shoes that you can still smell them, and near enough to the person wearing the shoes to take in the world from their perspective. You are trying to get a glance at their picture, if for but a fleeting moment.
The whole world seems to be smiling. Well, not the whole world, but everyone in my corner at this moment. That is what matters. The sun is streaming down and the wind dusting across the prairie in a soft autumn breeze. My joy feels complete. Despite the crowd I only really care about the one person attached to the hand that I am holding. He tightens his grasp, and his dancing eyes look back into mine. My breath catches in my chest as we forge on into the veil of bubbles. He is fully with me, and I with him. With.
Empathy is being with someone. It is when your presence is so strong to the other that they can sense your being with them spiritually, emotionally and physically. It is sharing yourself unabashedly. It is surrendering to the fact that as a receiver you can’t make the person understand just like you do, and as a giver you can’t change the receiver’s experience. But, that overall, through empathy you have the power to convey the message that as people living in relationship we are not alone. In our humanness we are able to share, to connect, to be with. To empathize.
The details of my journey into self and others along this road as a mother, partner, teacher, therapist and searching human being. Alas, as Rogers would say, on my becoming a person...
Monday, February 26, 2007
Wednesday, February 21, 2007
Hilarious.
Speaking of siblings, my brother made this and sent it to me just a bit ago...um, hilarious.
Here you are, me dancing with my Paul:
http://www.dancesisterdance.com/myvid/index.php?v=eeb08572c2113
Enjoy!
Here you are, me dancing with my Paul:
http://www.dancesisterdance.com/myvid/index.php?v=eeb08572c2113
Enjoy!
Ash Wednesday
Remember that you are from dust, and to dust you shall return.
I love this season in the church more than any other - the season compelling us to look inside and dig a little deeper. We spend time in introspection so that we may better our lives and ourselves today – not in some far off, imaginable future. It is a time to enjoy the darkness, for the darkness speaks of the depth in the light to come, and if the possibilities looming for change.
Since it is midweek and thus I’m in Chicago, I snuck quietly into an unknown little Lutheran church in Lakeview for the evening service. These days I cannot go into a Lutheran church without being absolutely seeped with emotion. How comforting is it that I can step into an unknown ELCA church anywhere and know the ritual of the liturgy will bring some familiarity? Beyond the liturgy, however, is the fact that every piece of it screams of my father. I feel the presence of his absence ever so strongly in the church, and especially during this season of Lent. It was his favorite place, his favorite time of the church year, as evidenced in my innate longing for his being during this time.
Tonight I also couldn’t stop thinking about the rest of my family and the long-gone days of being able to go to church together. All of the time I feel more tightly drawn to my sibs in our common history, and the older I get the more I realize the many ways no one else will know me as well as a result of our shared histories. I truly miss their presence during these celebrated moments of ritual. A far off dream is that someday Paul and my children will say the same – they will embrace the infinite value of family, the irreplaceable love and understanding amongst the typical familial dysfunction.
On that note, of member of my aforementioned sibling quartet deserves special recognition in this post. My dear sister Rachel will be celebrating her birthday tomorrow! In honor of her day, some of my favorite Rach memories…
Walking to elementary school together…taking turns carrying her trumpet and dodging the crab apples being thrown at us by the fifth grade boys. For sure I was proud that she had helped me tight roll my jeans before leaving the house.
Going to watch her sing in high school for Joynites and swing choir concerts. I was pretty convinced there was nothing cooler than my sister(s) in those moments of high school music bliss.
When she came to watch me practice for Pomalink auditions despite the fact that she was totally opposed to my auditioning. That’s love.
Musicals. What more can I say?
Singing that one duet from Miss Saigon at the piano in the living room…what is the name of that again Rach?
One fateful summer in Florid when she gave me the Vagina Monologues for "beach reading." Oh if she even knew how she opened my naïve little eyes in that simple act…
Talking on the phone my first semester of college and the realization that I was growing up – and that my sister and I could talk not just as sisters but also as friends.
Her support and laughter during the wedding prep and process – sucking it up more than once for my sake.
So Rachel, my brilliant and beautiful sister, may you be celebrated and showered with love on your day. I have looked up to you for as long as I can remember, big sis of mine! Loves.
I love this season in the church more than any other - the season compelling us to look inside and dig a little deeper. We spend time in introspection so that we may better our lives and ourselves today – not in some far off, imaginable future. It is a time to enjoy the darkness, for the darkness speaks of the depth in the light to come, and if the possibilities looming for change.
Since it is midweek and thus I’m in Chicago, I snuck quietly into an unknown little Lutheran church in Lakeview for the evening service. These days I cannot go into a Lutheran church without being absolutely seeped with emotion. How comforting is it that I can step into an unknown ELCA church anywhere and know the ritual of the liturgy will bring some familiarity? Beyond the liturgy, however, is the fact that every piece of it screams of my father. I feel the presence of his absence ever so strongly in the church, and especially during this season of Lent. It was his favorite place, his favorite time of the church year, as evidenced in my innate longing for his being during this time.
Tonight I also couldn’t stop thinking about the rest of my family and the long-gone days of being able to go to church together. All of the time I feel more tightly drawn to my sibs in our common history, and the older I get the more I realize the many ways no one else will know me as well as a result of our shared histories. I truly miss their presence during these celebrated moments of ritual. A far off dream is that someday Paul and my children will say the same – they will embrace the infinite value of family, the irreplaceable love and understanding amongst the typical familial dysfunction.
On that note, of member of my aforementioned sibling quartet deserves special recognition in this post. My dear sister Rachel will be celebrating her birthday tomorrow! In honor of her day, some of my favorite Rach memories…
Walking to elementary school together…taking turns carrying her trumpet and dodging the crab apples being thrown at us by the fifth grade boys. For sure I was proud that she had helped me tight roll my jeans before leaving the house.
Going to watch her sing in high school for Joynites and swing choir concerts. I was pretty convinced there was nothing cooler than my sister(s) in those moments of high school music bliss.
When she came to watch me practice for Pomalink auditions despite the fact that she was totally opposed to my auditioning. That’s love.
Musicals. What more can I say?
Singing that one duet from Miss Saigon at the piano in the living room…what is the name of that again Rach?
One fateful summer in Florid when she gave me the Vagina Monologues for "beach reading." Oh if she even knew how she opened my naïve little eyes in that simple act…
Talking on the phone my first semester of college and the realization that I was growing up – and that my sister and I could talk not just as sisters but also as friends.
Her support and laughter during the wedding prep and process – sucking it up more than once for my sake.
So Rachel, my brilliant and beautiful sister, may you be celebrated and showered with love on your day. I have looked up to you for as long as I can remember, big sis of mine! Loves.
Monday, February 19, 2007
Not for sale.
Last week I took a master class at the Overture Center from modern dancer/choreographer Ron Brown. His movement is a fusion of traditional African dance, hip-hop and contemporary modern. He was a beautiful dancer and the movement lush and innovative. I was totally captivated. More than the movement, though, I was taken by his genuine investment in the meaning of his choreographic choices. Brown spends time every year in Africa learning and practicing all of the native dances. He kept reiterating the importance of the spirit of the dance, and the fact that the moment we put movement on stage, we've started to sell what we do and it has lost the spiritual element.
I see this problem so often in American dance today - perhaps the reason why I love both modern dance and dance therapy is that they seek the meaning in the movement vs. the virtuosity. The movement is about the raw essence of the body in motion, not about the tricks and glamour of it all.
I kept thinking about this all weekend. Friday night was the biannual dance at church, which, by the way, is awesome. I watched nearly 500 people of all ages dancing together and was very aware of the contrast between those lost in the movement and those aware of every step they took - the fact that they were indeed "on stage" as a dancer.
And then at church yesterday, the sermon talked about the fact that we as people are much more apt to believe what we see and experience as opposed to learned argument. To me this totally tied in to what Ron Brown had to say: when we put our faith "on stage" so to speak, it loses the essence of the spiritual. When we throw scripture or Biblical teaching around without backing up what we preach by the way we live, the actions are totally empty. We can't expect to make any impact unless the things we claim to believe are supported by the way we live our lives.
I see this problem so often in American dance today - perhaps the reason why I love both modern dance and dance therapy is that they seek the meaning in the movement vs. the virtuosity. The movement is about the raw essence of the body in motion, not about the tricks and glamour of it all.
I kept thinking about this all weekend. Friday night was the biannual dance at church, which, by the way, is awesome. I watched nearly 500 people of all ages dancing together and was very aware of the contrast between those lost in the movement and those aware of every step they took - the fact that they were indeed "on stage" as a dancer.
And then at church yesterday, the sermon talked about the fact that we as people are much more apt to believe what we see and experience as opposed to learned argument. To me this totally tied in to what Ron Brown had to say: when we put our faith "on stage" so to speak, it loses the essence of the spiritual. When we throw scripture or Biblical teaching around without backing up what we preach by the way we live, the actions are totally empty. We can't expect to make any impact unless the things we claim to believe are supported by the way we live our lives.
New fashion trend?
Well, I'm sure you've heard by now about Britney Spears' latest - shaving her head and getting herself a fancy new tattoo. I suppose after one day of rehab she deserved a little self-indulgence.
This only confirms that Ms. Spears is straight up CRAZY. I mean, as if we needed any verification.
In my field, this is what we call "psychotic break." Fer sure.
After an amazing weekend (hooray for BR's visit!) I awoke this morning nice and sick. Awesome. Gotta love the nasty congestion. So for now, that's all. Time for some more tea and sudafed...bleh.
This only confirms that Ms. Spears is straight up CRAZY. I mean, as if we needed any verification.
In my field, this is what we call "psychotic break." Fer sure.
After an amazing weekend (hooray for BR's visit!) I awoke this morning nice and sick. Awesome. Gotta love the nasty congestion. So for now, that's all. Time for some more tea and sudafed...bleh.
Friday, February 16, 2007
A blog.
This is my brand new blog. Whoa.
I've joined the blogging age. After joining the ranks of facebook and myspace, why not also blogspot?
Yesterday, as I pulled my pulley commuter suitcase through the slushy, dirt filled streets of downtown Chicago, I thought to myself, "hmmm, I think I'd like to start a blog." So here it is, a new posting board for the randomness going on inside of my head.
Welcome to my mind.
I've joined the blogging age. After joining the ranks of facebook and myspace, why not also blogspot?
Yesterday, as I pulled my pulley commuter suitcase through the slushy, dirt filled streets of downtown Chicago, I thought to myself, "hmmm, I think I'd like to start a blog." So here it is, a new posting board for the randomness going on inside of my head.
Welcome to my mind.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)